First on the chopping block is Mihoyo's Genshin Impact. Considered one of the most successful gacha games of all time, Genshin maintains a strong player rating and solid revenue performance, indicating a high-quality experience that attracts consistent spending. However, its monetization model can be costly, especially for players aiming to collect specific characters or maximize progression. While the game is enjoyable and polished, the value per dollar can vary significantly depending on spending habits.
Final verdict: Worth spending for moderate or controlled spenders, not ideal for completionists.
Up next is Honkai: Star Rail(HSR) which is also by Mihoyo. HSR generates strong revenue but has noticeably lower player ratings. This combination can indicate that while players are spending, they may not be fully satisfied with the experience. It may rely more on monetization pressure or limited-time incentives rather than long-term player value.
Final Verdict: Not recommended for players looking for good value.
Infold's Love and Deepspace(L&D) was the most successful gacha game of 2025. It combines the highest average revenue with consistently high player ratings, suggesting a healthy balance between monetization and player satisfaction. Players are not only spending, but they also appear to feel good about their experience. This indicates fair systems, rewarding progression, and a generally positive return on investment for paying users.
Final Verdict: Worth the money!
Moving on to Fate/Grand Order(Fate) by Delightworks. Fate ranks lower in both revenue and player ratings compared to the other titles. This suggests weaker engagement and less overall satisfaction. Players are neither spending heavily nor rating the experience highly, which points to a less compelling value proposition.
Final verdict: Not worth spending money on.
Last but not least is Uma Musume: Pretty Derby by Cygames. Uma Musume shows the highest player rating among the group but relatively low revenue. This suggests a player-friendly environment with less aggressive monetization. Players enjoy the game, but it does not heavily push spending, making it a safer option for those who want to spend casually without pressure.
Final verdict: Worth spending for casual players seeking a low-pressure experience.
Genshin Impact: Moderately WorthUrPulls
Honkai: Star Rail: Not so WorthUrPulls
Love and Deepspace: WorthUrPulls!
Fate/Grand Order: Not WorthUrPulls
Uma Musume: Pretty Derby: WorthUrPulls!